| # | Moment | Game |
|---|---|---|
| 6 | The Many Evil Possessions of Luigi | Various |
| 5 | The Many, Many Deaths | Super Mario 64 |
| 4 | The Bad Ending | Super Smash Bros. Ultimate |
| 3 | World -1 | Super Paper Mario |
| 2 | Bowser Getting Burned Alive | Various |
| 1 | Peach Getting Possessed by the Demon Shadow Queen | Super Paper Mario Thousand Year Door |
Honorable Mentions[]
| Moment | Game |
|---|---|
| Secret Boss Culex | Super Mario RPG |
| Spider-Peach and Zombie Mario Mods | Super Smash Bros. Ultimate & Super Mario Odyssey |
| Luigi’s Death | Super Smash Bros. Ultimate |